SM Energy is up 37% and Reddit still thinks it’s worth it

• SM Energy’s merger with Civitas Resources positions the company as a 4x trailing multibasin producer at a trailing P/E of $1.5 billion, but investors are questioning whether cost-cutting and asset sales could continue to erode profits as oil prices remain volatile.

• An analyst named NVIDIA just named his top 10 AI stocks in 2010. Get it for free here.

Based in Denver, Colorado, SM Energy is a leading independent energy company (NYSE: SM) is up 37% year-to-date as retail investors weigh whether the $12.8 billion merger with Civitas Resources, which successfully closes on Jan. 30, 2026, is a genuine scale play or a profit trap. Reddit Sentiment sits at 78 to 84 out of 100, firmly in bullish territory, even after SM missed Q4 estimates by a wide margin.

As far as the numbers go, investors are taking note because the Q4 note was true. Red Flag’s launch EPS came in at $0.83 vs. estimates of $0.73, while revenue of $705 million missed consensus of $846 million by 8%. The culprit was oil prices, which fell 16% year over year to $58.17 per barrel. Production held well at 206.8 MBoe/d, in line with guidance.

The discussion on Reddit is centered on r/walltreetbets, where a post titled “$750k on SM Energy (a worthless US oil producer)” has 66 upvotes and 98 comments. A high ratio of upvotes to comments indicates real discussion, not just passive agreement.

$750k on SM Energy (U.S. crude oil producer)
By a/anonymous on Wallstreet Beats

READ: The analyst named NVIDIA in 2010 Just naming his top 10 AI stocks

The running of the bell case discussed depends on three concrete factors:

This infographic details Reddit’s social sentiment for SM Energy’s $13 billion merger with Civitas Resources, highlighting the key arguments in Bell’s case and the company’s actions that fueled that sentiment.

• SM trades at nearly 4x trailing P/E, unusually cheap for E&P with a multi-basin asset base

• $185 million in synergies have already been executed against a target of $200-$300 million, with management pointing to a current valuation of $1.5 billion, roughly 30% of market capitalization.

• February 2026 WTI sits at $64.51 above SM’s $60/bbl plan assumption, which predicts 2026 free cash flow

CEO Beth MacDonald created three priorities around integration: “Integrate, Execute, Strengthen.” The reinforcement part is very important for skeptics. Net debt leverage stands at 1.05x, with a target to bring it down to the low 1s. The $950 million South Texas divestiture, expected to close in Q2 2026, is the clearest near-term lever for that goal.

SM is ahead of Devon Energy (NYSE:DVN) year-to-date, with SM up 37% versus Dion’s 25%, while the broader E&P sector, as measured by the SPDR S&P Oil & Gas Exploration & Production ETF (NYSEARCA:XOP), is up 30% year-to-date, meaning SM’s outperformance is real but not dramatic. The closing of the division and the Q1 production results will be the next concrete test of whether the integration thesis presents or just raises the risk level.

Wall Street is pouring billions into AI, but many investors are buying the wrong stocks. The analyst who first identified NVIDIA as a buyback in 2010 — before its 28,000% run — has identified just 10 new AI companies that he believes can deliver returns beyond that point. One dominates the $100 billion equipment market. Bill addresses the single biggest obstacle to maintaining AI data centers. The third segment is a net play in the optical network market that is quadrupling. Most investors haven’t heard of half of these names. Get a free list of all 10 stocks here.